Author(s): Luckett T, Goldstein D, Butow PN, Gebski V, Aldridge LJ, et al.
Background: Ethnic minority is associated with higher cancer incidence and poorer survival than is being in the majority group. We did a systematic review and meta-analysis to assess whether psychological morbidity and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) were affected by minority status.
Methods: We searched Medline, AMED, PsycINFO, Embase, CENTRAL, CINAHL, PubMed, Sociological Abstracts, and Web of Science for English-language articles published between Jan 1, 1995, and October, 2009. Articles were eligible if they reported original data on anxiety, depression, distress (for psychological morbidity), or HRQoL in minority and majority cancer patients or survivors. Minority status was defined as being an immigrant or having an ethnic, linguistic, or religious background different to the majority of the population in the country where the research was done. We excluded African Americans and indigenous groups. Eligible articles were rated for quality of reporting, external validity, internal validity, sample size, and power. Each quality criterion was rated independently by two reviewers until inter-rater reliability was achieved. In a meta-analysis we compared mean scores adjusted for socioeconomic status and other sociodemographic and clinical variables, where available. Effect sizes greater than 0·5 and 95% CI that included 0·5 or -0·5 were deemed clinically important, with negative values indicating worse outcomes in minority patients. We assessed publication bias by estimating the number of potential unpublished studies and the number of non-signficant studies with p=0·05 required to produce a non-significant overall result.
Findings: We identified 21 eligible articles that included 18 datasets collected in the USA and one in each of Canada, Romania, and the UK. Ethnic minority groups were Hispanic, Asian or Pacific Islander, or Hungarian (one dataset). Overall, we found minority versus majority groups to have significantly worse distress (mean difference -0·37, 95% CI -0·46 to -0·28; p<0·0001), depression (-0·23, -0·36 to -0·11; p=0·0003), and overall HRQoL (-0·33, -0·58 to -0·07; p=0·013). Further analyses found disparities to be specific to Hispanic patients in the USA, in whom poorer outcomes were consistent with potentially clinically important differences for distress (effect size -0·37, 95% CI -0·54 to -0·20; p<0·0001), social HRQoL (-0·45, -0·87 to -0·03; p=0·035), and overall HRQoL (-0·49, -0·78 to -0.20; p=0·0008). Results were significantly heterogeneous for overall HRQoL and all domains. Tests for interaction, for adjusted versus unadjusted and comparisons of high-quality, medium-quality, and low-quality articles, were generally non-significant, which suggests no bias. We found no evidence of any substantive publication bias.
Interpretation: Hispanic cancer patients in the USA, but not other ethnic minority groups, report significantly worse distress, depression, social HRQoL, and overall HRQoL than do majority patients, of which all but depression might be clinically important. Heterogeneous results might, however, have limited the interpretation. Data for other minority groups and for anxiety are scarce. More studies are needed from outside the USA. Future reports should more clearly describe their minority group samples and analyses should control for clinical and sociodemographic variables known to predict outcomes. Understanding of why outcomes are poor in US Hispanic patients is needed to inform the targeting of interventions.
Funding: Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney, Australia.
Referred From: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21996168
Author(s): National Cancer Institute
Author(s): American Cancer Society
Author(s): Mellon S, Northouse LL
Author(s): Mertens DM
Author(s): Schmidt JE, Andrykowski MA
Author(s): Buki LP, Garces DM, Hinestrosa MC, Kogan L, Carrillo IY,
Author(s): Galván N, Buki LP, Garcés DM
Author(s): Clark R, Anderson NB, Clark VR, Williams DR
Author(s): Cooper LA, Hill MN, Powe NR
Author(s): Kreps GL, Sparks L
Author(s): Hall IJ, Rim SH, Johnson-Turbes CA, Vanderpool R, Kamalu NN
Author(s): Joseph G, Kaplan C, Luce J, Lee R, Stewart S, et al.
Author(s): Banegas MP, Li CI
Author(s): Mujahid MS, Janz NK, Hawley ST, Griggs JJ, Hamilton AS, et al.
Author(s): Janz NK, Hawley ST, Mujahid MS, Griggs JJ, Alderman A, et al.
Author(s): Mujahid MS, Janz NK, Hawley ST, Griggs JJ, Hamilton AS, et al.
Author(s): DeSantis C, Jemal A, Ward E
Author(s): Barry J, Breen N, Barrett M
Author(s): Fagundes CP, Bennett JM, Alfano CM, Glaser R, Povoski SP, et al.
Author(s): Berz JP, Johnston K, Backus B, Doros G, Rose AJ, et al.
Author(s): Burton LM, Bonilla-Silva E, Ray V, Buckelew R, Freeman EH
Author(s): Kuo TM, Mobley LR, Anselin L
Author(s): Kravdal H, Syse A
Author(s): Nayeri K, Pitaro G, Feldman JG
Author(s): Osborne C, Ostir GV, Du X, Peek MK, Goodwin JS
Author(s): Taira N, Shimozuma K, Shiroiwa T, Ohsumi S, Kuroi K, et al
Author(s): Wittenberg L, Yutsis M, Taylor S, Giese-Davis J, Bliss-Isberg C, et al.
Author(s): McColl MA, Skinner H
Author(s): Glanz K, Lewis FM, Rimer BK
Author(s): Jensen KP, Bäck-Pettersson S, Segesten K
Author(s): Trinkaus M, Burman D, Barmala N, Rodin G, Jones J, et al.
Author(s): Raveis VH, Pretter S
Author(s): Fobair P, Spiegel D
Author(s): Shelby RA, Crespin TR, Wells-Di Gregorio SM, Lamdan RM, Siegel JE, et al.
Author(s): Janz NK, Mujahid MS, Hawley ST, Griggs JJ, Alderman A, et al.
Author(s): Davey MP, Kissil K, Niño A, Tubbs CY
Author(s): Hamilton JB, Agarwal M, Carter JK, Crandell JL
Author(s): Hamilton JB, Sandelowski M
Author(s): Williams KP, Mullan PB, Todem D
Author(s): Ashing-Giwa KT, Ganz PA
Author(s): Ashing-Giwa KT, Padilla GV, Bohórquez DE, Tejero JS, Garcia M
Author(s): Wildes KA, Miller AR, de Majors SS, Ramirez AG
Author(s): Mullan F
Author(s): Yang HC, Schuler TA
Author(s): Fang CY, Manne SL, Pape SJ
Author(s): Vahdaninia M, Omidvari S, Montazeri A
Author(s): Karakoyun-Celik O1, Gorken I, Sahin S, Orcin E, Alanyali H, et al.
Author(s): Kneece J
Author(s): Dorval M, Maunsell E, Taylor-Brown J, Kilpatrick M
Author(s): Taylor-Brown J, Kilpatrick M, Maunsell E, Dorval M
Author(s): Antonucci TC, Birditt KS, Webster NJ
Author(s): Birditt K, Antonucci TC
Author(s): Kroenke CH, Michael Y, Tindle H, Gage E, Chlebowski R, et al.
Author(s): Talley A, Molix L, Schlegel RJ, Bettencourt A
Author(s): White JL, Boehmer U
Author(s): Boehmer U, Freund KM, Linde R
Author(s): Fergus KD, Gray RE
Author(s): Manne SL, Ostroff J, Winkel G, Grana G, Fox K
Author(s): Perz J, Ussher JM, Butow P, Wain G
Author(s): Ganz PA, Rowland JH, Desmond K, Meyerowitz BE, Wyatt GE
Author(s): Legg M, Occhipinti S, Ferguson M, Dunn J, Chambers SK
Author(s): Chou AF, Stewart SL, Wild RC, Bloom JR
Author(s): Park JH, Bae SH, Jung YS, Kim KS
Author(s): Bjorneklett HG, Lindemalm C, Rosenblad A, Ojutkangas M, Letocha H, et al.
Author(s): Matthews AK, Tejeda S, Johnson TP, Berbaum ML, Manfredi C
Author(s): Friedman LC, Barber CR, Chang J, Tham YL, Kalidas M, et al.
Author(s): Levine EG, Aviv C, Yoo G, Ewing C, Au A
Author(s): Janiszewska J, Buss T, de Walden-Gałuszko K, Majkowicz M, Lichodziejewska-Niemierko M, et al.
Author(s): Braun B, Marghi JR
Author(s): Lewis KG, Moon S
Author(s): Sheppard VB, Adams IF, Lamdan R, Taylor KL
Author(s): Schreiber JA, Brockopp DY
Author(s): Dyson GJ, Thompson K, Palmer S, Thomas DM, Schofield P
Author(s): Elkins G, Fisher W, Johnson A
Author(s): Beatty LJ, Adams J, Sibbritt D, Wade TD
Author(s): Spadacio C, Barros NF
Author(s): Geue K, Goetze H, Buttstaedt M, Kleinert E, Richter D, et al.
Author(s): Bar-Sela G, Atid L, Danos S, Gabay N, Epelbaum R
Author(s): Puig A, Lee SM, Goodwin L, Sherrard PAD
Author(s): Lin K, Hu Y, Chang K, Lin H, Tsauo J
Author(s): Danhauer SC, Mihalko SL, Russell GB, Campbell CR, Felder L, et al.
Author(s): Moadel AB, Shah C, Wylie-Rosett J, Harris MS, Patel SR, et al.